The Blockchain Selection Challenge
When building a verification platform, the blockchain layer is critical. It needs to be:
- Cost-effective - Our customers anchor millions of records
- Fast - Users expect quick confirmations
- Secure - Data integrity is our core promise
- Reliable - Production systems need 99.9%+ uptime
- Developer-friendly - We need good tooling and documentation
We evaluated multiple options before choosing Polygon. Here's our analysis.
The Candidates
We seriously evaluated five blockchain options:
| Blockchain | Type | Avg Gas Fee | Finality |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ethereum Mainnet | Layer 1 | $5-50+ | 12-15 min |
| Polygon PoS | Layer 2 (Sidechain) | $0.001-0.01 | 5-10 sec |
| Arbitrum | Layer 2 (Optimistic) | $0.10-0.50 | ~1 week* |
| Solana | Layer 1 | $0.00025 | ~12 sec |
| BSC (BNB Chain) | Layer 1 | $0.05-0.20 | ~3 sec |
*Arbitrum's optimistic rollup has a 7-day challenge period for withdrawals, though transactions are usable immediately.
Why Not Ethereum Mainnet?
Ethereum is the most secure and decentralized public blockchain, but for a verification service, the costs are prohibitive:
Scenario: 10,000 records per day
Gas per transaction: ~50,000 gas
Average gas price: 30 gwei
ETH price: $3,000
Cost per transaction: 50,000 × 30 × 10⁻⁹ × $3,000
= $4.50 per transaction
With Merkle batching (256 records/TX):
Daily transactions: 10,000 ÷ 256 = 40 TXs
Daily cost: 40 × $4.50 = $180/day
Monthly cost: $5,400/month
// Too expensive for most use cases
At $5,400/month just for blockchain fees, Ethereum mainnet isn't viable for high-volume applications.
Why Not Solana?
Solana offers extremely low fees, but we had concerns:
- Network stability: Multiple outages in 2022-2023
- Different programming model: Rust-based, not EVM-compatible
- Tooling maturity: Less mature than Ethereum ecosystem
- Decentralization concerns: Fewer validators than Ethereum/Polygon
Why Polygon?
After extensive evaluation, Polygon PoS emerged as the clear winner. Here's why:
1. Extremely Low Fees
Polygon's fees make enterprise-scale anchoring economically viable:
Scenario: 10,000 records per day
Gas per transaction: ~52,000 gas
Average gas price: 30 gwei (similar to Ethereum)
MATIC price: $1.00
Cost per transaction: 52,000 × 30 × 10⁻⁹ × $1.00
= $0.00156 per transaction
≈ $0.001 per transaction
With Merkle batching (256 records/TX):
Daily transactions: 10,000 ÷ 256 = 40 TXs
Daily cost: 40 × $0.001 = $0.04/day
Monthly cost: $1.20/month
Cost per record: $0.04 ÷ 10,000 = $0.000004
// 4,500x cheaper than Ethereum mainnet!
2. Fast Finality
Polygon provides practical finality in 5-10 seconds:
| Metric | Polygon | Ethereum |
|---|---|---|
| Block time | ~2 seconds | ~12 seconds |
| Confirmations for safety | ~5 blocks | ~32 blocks |
| Practical finality | 5-10 seconds | ~6 minutes |
This means users get blockchain confirmation for their anchored data within seconds, not minutes.
3. Ethereum Compatibility
Polygon is EVM-compatible, which means:
- Same tooling: ethers.js, web3.js, Hardhat, Remix all work
- Same language: Solidity smart contracts
- Same addresses: 0x format Ethereum addresses
- Easy migration: Can deploy same contracts to Ethereum if needed
import { ethers } from 'ethers';
// Same code works for both networks - just change RPC URL
const provider = new ethers.JsonRpcProvider(
'https://polygon-mainnet.infura.io/v3/YOUR_KEY' // Polygon
// 'https://mainnet.infura.io/v3/YOUR_KEY' // Ethereum
);
const wallet = new ethers.Wallet(privateKey, provider);
// Deploy contract - identical on both chains
const AnchoraAnchor = await ethers.getContractFactory('AnchoraAnchor');
const contract = await AnchoraAnchor.deploy();
// Anchor Merkle root - same interface
const tx = await contract.anchorRoot(merkleRoot, recordCount);
const receipt = await tx.wait();
console.log('Block:', receipt.blockNumber);
console.log('Gas used:', receipt.gasUsed.toString());
4. Security Model
Polygon PoS uses a Proof of Stake consensus with:
- 100+ validators: Decentralized block production
- Checkpointing to Ethereum: State roots committed to Ethereum mainnet periodically
- Battle-tested: Billions of dollars secured since 2020
- Bug bounty program: Active security research
5. Mature Ecosystem
Polygon has excellent infrastructure:
- Block explorers: Polygonscan (same interface as Etherscan)
- RPC providers: Infura, Alchemy, QuickNode all support Polygon
- Development tools: Full Hardhat, Foundry, Remix support
- Testnet: Amoy testnet for development (previously Mumbai)
- Documentation: Extensive guides and API references
Our Smart Contract
Here's our actual smart contract deployed on Polygon (simplified):
// SPDX-License-Identifier: MIT
pragma solidity ^0.8.19;
contract AnchoraAnchor {
struct Batch {
bytes32 merkleRoot;
uint256 timestamp;
address operator;
uint256 recordCount;
}
mapping(uint256 => Batch) public batches;
uint256 public totalBatches;
event RootAnchored(
uint256 indexed batchId,
bytes32 merkleRoot,
uint256 timestamp,
address operator,
uint256 recordCount
);
/// @notice Anchor a Merkle root to the blockchain
/// @param _merkleRoot The root hash of the Merkle tree
/// @param _recordCount Number of records in this batch
function anchorRoot(
bytes32 _merkleRoot,
uint256 _recordCount
) external returns (uint256 batchId) {
batchId = totalBatches++;
batches[batchId] = Batch({
merkleRoot: _merkleRoot,
timestamp: block.timestamp,
operator: msg.sender,
recordCount: _recordCount
});
emit RootAnchored(
batchId,
_merkleRoot,
block.timestamp,
msg.sender,
_recordCount
);
}
/// @notice Verify a Merkle proof on-chain
function verifyProof(
uint256 _batchId,
bytes32 _leaf,
bytes32[] calldata _proof
) external view returns (bool) {
bytes32 computedRoot = _leaf;
for (uint256 i = 0; i < _proof.length; i++) {
bytes32 proofElement = _proof[i];
if (computedRoot < proofElement) {
computedRoot = keccak256(
abi.encodePacked(computedRoot, proofElement)
);
} else {
computedRoot = keccak256(
abi.encodePacked(proofElement, computedRoot)
);
}
}
return computedRoot == batches[_batchId].merkleRoot;
}
/// @notice Get batch details
function getBatch(uint256 _batchId)
external
view
returns (
bytes32 merkleRoot,
uint256 timestamp,
address operator,
uint256 recordCount
)
{
Batch storage batch = batches[_batchId];
return (
batch.merkleRoot,
batch.timestamp,
batch.operator,
batch.recordCount
);
}
}
Gas Costs in Practice
Here are our actual gas costs on Polygon:
| Operation | Gas Used | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| anchorRoot() - 1 record | ~50,000 | ~$0.001 |
| anchorRoot() - 256 records (batch) | ~52,000 | ~$0.001 |
| verifyProof() on-chain | ~30,000 | ~$0.0006 |
| getBatch() - read only | 0 (view function) | Free |
Development Workflow
Our development workflow with Polygon:
1. LOCAL DEVELOPMENT
└─ Hardhat local node (instant transactions, free)
└─ Unit tests with Hardhat
2. TESTNET (Polygon Amoy)
└─ Free MATIC from faucet
└─ Real network conditions
└─ View transactions on amoy.polygonscan.com
3. MAINNET (Polygon PoS)
└─ Real MATIC (~$1 per token)
└─ ~$0.001 per transaction
└─ View on polygonscan.com
Configuration in hardhat.config.js:
─────────────────────────────────
networks: {
hardhat: {}, // Local testing
amoy: { // Testnet
url: "https://polygon-amoy.infura.io/v3/KEY",
accounts: [TESTNET_PRIVATE_KEY]
},
polygon: { // Mainnet
url: "https://polygon-mainnet.infura.io/v3/KEY",
accounts: [MAINNET_PRIVATE_KEY]
}
}
Viewing Transactions
Every anchored batch can be viewed on Polygonscan:
Transaction Hash: 0xb706858a2c9e4a8e3d5f9c1a2b3d4e5f...
Block Number: 45,123,789
Timestamp: Jan 18, 2026 10:30:45 AM UTC
From: 0x742d35Cc6634C0532925a3b844Bc9e7595f...
To: 0xAnchoraContract...
Value: 0 MATIC
Gas Used: 52,341
Gas Price: 30 gwei
Transaction Fee: 0.00157023 MATIC (~$0.00157)
Input Data:
Function: anchorRoot(bytes32,uint256)
merkleRoot: 0x9876543210fedcba9876543210fedcba...
recordCount: 256
Event Emitted:
RootAnchored(
batchId: 30,
merkleRoot: 0x9876...,
timestamp: 1737196245,
operator: 0x742d35...,
recordCount: 256
)
View at: https://polygonscan.com/tx/0xb706858a...
Future Considerations
While Polygon PoS is our current choice, we're monitoring:
Polygon zkEVM
Polygon's zero-knowledge rollup offers even stronger security guarantees. We may migrate to zkEVM once it matures further.
Multi-Chain Support
Some customers want anchoring on specific chains (Ethereum mainnet for maximum security, Arbitrum for specific ecosystems). We're evaluating multi-chain deployment.
Data Availability
Solutions like EigenDA and Celestia could further reduce costs while maintaining security. We're watching this space.
Conclusion
Polygon PoS provides the optimal balance for a verification service:
4,500x cheaper than Ethereum mainnet
Near-instant confirmation for users
Checkpointing to Ethereum mainnet
Same tools, same code, same ecosystem
Combined with Merkle tree batching (256 records per transaction), we achieve $0.000004 per record - making enterprise-scale blockchain anchoring economically viable.
Ready to anchor your data to Polygon?
Start with our free tier - 10,000 records per month, no credit card required.
Get Your API Key